Your CPA and Wealth Advisor Should Be on the Same Team
A good outcome does not require one firm. It requires one coordinated plan.
Should your CPA and financial advisor work together? Yes, whenever a decision crosses both fields. The CPA sees tax attributes and entity structure. Meanwhile, the advisor sees the portfolio, liquidity, and goals. With your written permission to share information, both can work from the same facts before you act, rather than reconstructing decisions at tax time.
Many financial decisions have tax consequences. Similarly, many tax decisions have financial consequences.
Yet CPAs and wealth advisors often work in separate lanes. The CPA sees the tax return, business entities, income character, and carryforwards. The wealth advisor sees the investment portfolio, liquidity needs, risk tolerance, and long-term goals.
Both may still give sound advice based on the information available to them. But good advice can still produce a poor overall result when each professional sees only part of the picture.
A reasonable strategy based on incomplete information
Consider a hypothetical client whose wealth advisor is actively harvesting investment losses. In isolation, the strategy is reasonable. What the advisor does not know is that the client already has substantial unused tax attributes from an earlier business sale, including significant capital-loss carryforwards.
The CPA knows those carryforwards exist. Meanwhile, the wealth advisor understands the investments. Neither fact is particularly useful until the two professionals communicate.
Once they do, the client can reconsider the purpose of the portfolio. This client also holds a significant portion of the family’s net worth in private businesses and other private investments. Those assets create their own risks, cash flows, and changing mix of ordinary, capital-gain, and passive income.
As a result, no one can evaluate the investment portfolio as a standalone account.
The advisor can reassess risk tolerance across the client’s business interests, investment portfolio, estate, and generational objectives. The client might sell lower-conviction holdings with significant unrealized gains sooner than planned. That lets the advisor diversify and reposition the portfolio without overstating the tax cost of doing so.
The rebalance might have happened eventually anyway, with a similar tax result. That is the point. In other words, collaboration does not create a special tax strategy. It removes a false constraint so the client can make the investment decision on its economic merits, without unnecessary delay or stress.
Taxes should inform investment decisions. However, they should not trap a client in an investment strategy that no longer makes economic sense.
Different expertise. One financial life.
Each professional brings a different perspective:
- The CPA understands tax attributes, entity structure, business income, estimated payments, and how decisions will appear on the return.
- The wealth advisor understands portfolio construction, liquidity, investment risk, time horizon, and how assets support personal and family goals.
- You, the client, understand the family, business, priorities, and tradeoffs that neither professional’s software can show.
Collaboration does not require either advisor to surrender responsibility or compete for the relationship. Instead, it requires each professional to recognize where a decision crosses into the other’s field.
The goal is not for everyone to give the same advice. Rather, the goal is for each advisor’s advice to reflect the same facts.
How can a CPA and financial advisor work together?
- Authorize communication. Give your CPA and wealth advisor written permission to exchange relevant information. CPAs generally need your written consent before sharing tax return information, even with another advisor you already work with. The IRS Section 7216 information center explains the consent rules for tax return preparers.
- Coordinate before acting. Rebalancing, business distributions, Roth conversions, charitable gifts, major purchases, and business transactions deserve review before execution, not during tax preparation.
- Define who owns the next step. Coordination fails when everyone assumes someone else is responsible. Each significant decision should have a clear lead advisor and an implementation timeline.
- Ask about the whole picture. Evaluate recommendations based on taxes, risk, liquidity, business exposure, estate objectives, and family goals rather than optimizing one variable in isolation.
Start with one question
At the next meeting with either advisor, ask:
What does my other advisor need to know before we act?
That question does not require changing CPAs, replacing an investment advisor, or moving every relationship under one roof. It simply recognizes that a client has one financial life, even when several professionals help advise it.
Good advisors do not compete to control the whole picture. They collaborate so the client can see it.
Next in this series: When Tax Strategy and Investment Strategy Work Against Each Other
About this article
This article is Part 2 of One Financial Life, a six-part series for business owners. To check any adviser’s registration, use the SEC’s Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site. Related reading: How the two roles differ; Tax-efficient wealth management.
Cooper Norman, PLLC and Cooper Norman Wealth, LLC are separate and distinct companies, providing separate and distinct services. Tax and accounting services are provided by Cooper Norman, PLLC. Investment advisory services are offered through Cooper Norman Wealth, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Cooper Norman Wealth, LLC does not provide tax or legal advice. Examples in this article are hypothetical illustrations; they do not describe any specific client, and similar results should not be expected. This content is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and is not personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Please consult your own advisors about your specific circumstances.
Tax attributes, including net operating losses and capital-loss carryforwards, are subject to different limitations and should be evaluated based on the taxpayer's specific circumstances.